"I disagree Kris. There are software solutions that could automatically scale and crop for you based on white ,or in this case black, space. I also think that people have certain expectations when they dock any device (not only nowadays but since mainstream docks have been available ie. pre-2012), it's all about familiarity and that dictates that there should have been a charging circuit. This information is the sort of feedback I would have expected them to receive during user testing."